Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I thought degradation of optical medium was already pretty well understood? (And happened on timescales generally longer than FB has been in operation)


There is Blu-ray compatible archival disk format that the manufacturers claim will last 1000 years: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M-DISC

I don't know how this claim could be verified in our lifetimes.


I've done accelerated aging on polymers (medical, but I bet it's similar).

We have an accelerated aging experiment, and we sample the part for degradation throughout the test. We also "shelf age" another test group of polymers from the same batch by placing them on the shelf.

Every year or so (or sometimes 5 year spans), we take the shelf samples and look for degradation, and compare it to the accelerated data.

In one polymer's specific case, free radicals in the polymer chain slowly react with oxygen and that's how it breaks down (takes about 10 years if the polymer isn't stable), so our accelerated aging is to put in in a pressure vessel full of high-pressure oxygen, and apply a little heat. We can get 10 years of degradation (roughly) within 2 weeks.

This is almost certainly what the archival blu-ray format has done and is doing.


I was too young at the time optical medium was everywhere to search for actual data, and public claims were contradictory (5 years, 10 years .. more .. ). And that was CD-ROM density.

Interestingly, http://blog.digistor.com/the-unparalleled-durability-of-blu-... says that there were new design constraint in blurays making them much more durable.


Perhaps Amazon's Glacier center operates in a lights-out environment with a decreased oxygen environment to increase the life span of the discs.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: