Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Please someone contradict me and make a more reasoned argument.

The FARC sells cocaine. The Afghan warlords sell heroin. There is no constellation of American political interests for which "Legalize cocaine and heroin" is even remotely conceivable as an achievable policy option.

Incidentally, no matter what you legalize, smuggling remains a viable option for whatever it is you don't. FARC could just as easily be the world's largest kiddie porn or sex slave ring. Afghanistan could sell slaves.

(I am not speaking hypothetically. There are nations which do both. A willingness to do evil plus a local monopoly on coercive force makes for a very profitable combination.)



Your argument is specious.

The total addressable market for heroin and cocaine consumption is demonstrably high. Kiddie porn demand will never reach this level, and hiding a sex slave in your house is difficult.


Funny that you say that.

In Japan there's a whole (legal) industry that would be probably classified as "kiddie porn" distribution in US. It's certainly bigger than the local cocaine and heroine market.


What's legal in Japan creeps me out, but what's illegal in the US is often silly.


You'll be happy to know that freedom of expression is slowly being crushed in Japan, just like everywhere else, so you won't have to feel creeped out much longer.

http://www.sankakucomplex.com/2009/08/21/un-demands-hentai-b... (possibly NSFW)


The UN's obscure subdepartments can demand, but Japan doesn't have to comply. And considering the size of the market for hentai, I don't think it's going to go away any time soon.


> (legal)

Not in the de jure sense, surely?

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=630032


You know, Portugal did decriminalize cocaine and heroin use five years ago, and it seems to be effective.


Whether or not a given measure is effective has little to do with whether it is an achievable goal in the U.S. political system.


Little, but not nothing.


This is one of the main points right wing pundits make against legalizing pot too.

I wonder what bootleggers started to sell after alcohol was legalized in the US.


I'm sure the Afghan warlords would be happy to sell morphine or codeine if they could sell on the legitimate international opiate market. However, they're not allowed and this dramatically increases the price of medical opium.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: