Actually, I think the noise proves his point. The fact that adding so much noise was necessary means computers are pretty good at solving that problem, and it has to be made next to impossible for humans before computers can no longer solve it either.
I've heard a lot of anecdotal evidence that young blind people have better-than-average hearing, but what about the elderly?
I'm not sure anyone I know over 70 years old could pass either of those captchas. I guess the only consolation is that most people that age often have younger people sign up for them.
https://www.google.com/accounts/NewAccount