Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Developers are often seen with MacBook Pros. For example, RailsConf: http://flickr.com/photos/twylo/173895378/

With the new MacBook/Pros, it's basically whether you want a bigger screen or not, and if you want more GHz of processing power. There are 2.0 and 2.4GHz MacBooks available, $1300 and $1600, respectively, and MacBook Pros start at 2.4 up, starting at $2000.

To put things in perspective, here is what you're getting for $400 more in the MacBook Pro 2.4GHz than the MacBook 2.4GHz:

  - bigger screen
  - extra NVidia <strike>8600M</strike> 9600M GT graphics card
  - FireWire port and ExpressCard port
  - and of course, 2" more of real estate.
Or, you might be okay with the 2.0GHz MacBook, if all you are doing is Rails work, in which case you would save another $300.

So the question basically is, 1) do you want 2.0 or 2.4GHz (suggest 2.4), and 2) do you want the bigger screen, and if so, if that is worth $400 to you (along with the other stuff.)



In 2008, does anything use the ExpressCard port that you care about? Isn't it basically obsolete?

You'd say the same about Firewire --- except:

* Losing Firewire also costs you "target disk mode", which lets you mount another Mac as an otherwise inert external hard drive, which is hugely helpful for backing up and restoring machines.

* Firewire is the standard remote debugging interface for the Windows kernel, and is an all-around great debugging interface (Firewire itself is basically nothing but a network protocol hooked directly up to a DMA engine); there's no perfect replacement for it that I know of.


ExpressCard is obsolete, and I don't care about it. That's just a list of the differences between MB and MBP.

It's only useful if you have an old EVDO/3G card that relies on ExpressCard.


To be picky, whether or not you want/need the bigger screen with you all the time. I have only a MacBook and I use it with a 20" lcd at home, which is where I do the majority of my work. (I also have more than one desktop, so if the laptop is going to be a sole machine, yet another thing to take into consideration.)

I couldn't justify the additional cost, size/weight and fragility of a MBP over a regular MB, having owned one previously. My productivity doesn't suffer with Spaces and Expose on the 13" widescreen (although this is personal preference), and the external display is a cherry on top of the cake.

Of course, you could also do the same thing with a MBP, but assuming that budget may be a limiting factor and all..


Not 8600M, but 9600M GT.

Also, the screen is not only bigger, but much much higher quality in the MBP.

No one is mentioning the MBA?




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: