Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I never really understood the use case, despite people I know wildly effusing the benefits.

I have a google smart speaker thing precisely because it's the only device that I can integrate with my Nest cameras and devices (which I bought before the Google acquisition). It does 2 things: 1) announce door bell ringing, and 2) play Apple Music in my office.

For everything else Siri, whilst demonstrably behind the curve of Amazon and Google, is perfectly functional - dictating short messages whilst walking, adding to a shared shopping list, setting timers.

I already have the phone for other reasons, there's no use case for buying an Alexa device that I can see.

I would never make a purchase from Amazon on an Alexa using my voice - there's simply too many variables that I can't control for. It might misunderstand (possibly catastrophically costing me a huge amount of money and inconvenience), the quality of goods on Amazon is too low and generally too variable to allow a an Amazon AI to be the arbiter of which product to buy for me, and even the manual purchase process changes too often and too subtly to have confidence that it won't add something that I don't want (i.e., a regular subscription to a product, pay on a credit arrangement, etc).



> adding to a shared shopping list

This hasn't worked for me since iOS 13, I think, and macOS, too. Getting a "Sorry, can't help with that".




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: