Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Wait... why are we having people do this anyway? Backscatter scans would be perfect if it wasn't for the privacy problem, so why aren't we using image processing software to look for objectionable objects etc instead of people?


> Backscatter scans would be perfect if it wasn't for the privacy problem

What about the safety problem? A few academics at UCSF drafted an open letter regarding the safety backscatter scanners, available at http://www.npr.org/assets/news/2010/05/17/concern.pdf

Reading it firmly shifted my objection from one based on privacy to one based on safety. Therac-25 wasn't that long ago, after all. And, of course, let's not forget shoe fitting fluoroscopes.


Let's follow this line of reasoning. Suppose your image recognition software noticed something it thought was suspicious. What are you going to do about it? Have a human look at the backscatter picture? Do a pat-down? Either way, you're cutting down on the privacy invasion, but not eliminating it.

That's probably worthwhile, but I doubt it'll make people feel much better about the machines, and it'll piss off the people who will see it as backing down on airport security.


Maybe it's easier to blame people than software? Or maybe we don't have enough samples of bomb carrying people to train software with?


Because you haven't done it yet.

Do it, prove that it works, get a political or corporate sponsor for your product to roll it out, and help to solve this growing war between personal liberty and government security.


Because that doesn't create jobs. And every politician will tell you that we need to be creating jobs in these horrible times.


And were it not for the human rights and false accusation issues, simply arresting EVERYBODY would be perfect!

The privacy issues with backscatter scans are not incidental. Even with software processing they would still very much be present.


People distrust technology. Even in cases where it's more reliable than a human (and I'm not sure this would be one), there's an inherent mistrust of machines making decisions.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: