Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

If all the "bad guys" who distribute illegal material do so encrypted volumes and refuse to give up the decryption key then what do we do ?

"Bad guys" still have fifth amendment protection. You prosecute, satisfy the burden of proof and hope a jury convicts. That's what you do.

Outside of that, if you really want this changed, petition your representative to repeal the fifth amendment, I suppose?



need to stop thinking from an american centric perspective.


This is in response to a news story that happened in the United States, I thought we were remaining in that context. And if I'm to think outside of an American-centric viewpoint, what governing body do you point to that would protect someone's rights from being forced to provide evidence against themselves when being charged with a crime?

or

Is this something that ought not be considered either?


I think it is right to think in a american context here because no other western country would hold someone for so long just because he probably forgot his password. This is obviously a american issue.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: