Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

My question might be very stupid, but I am genuinely curious:

I assumed a quantum computer is fundamentally different to a classical one and thus you needed actual quantum physics to build this kind of computer. So how can you simulate the quantum computer on a classical one?



We can mathematically describe how a quantum computer works, so we can implement the mathematics in a classical computer. It's just slow (=higher complexity) in comparison. A quantum computer AFAIK can't solve any problems a normal computer couldn't solve, but it is a lot more efficient for some of them.


> A quantum computer AFAIK can't solve any problems a normal computer couldn't solve, but it is a lot more efficient for some of them.

Technically correct, but some of the problems we want quantum computers to solve are currently infeasible by conventional means because of speed. Factorization for example, that's why public key encryption works (we can't brute force it), but a quantum computer could.


I didn't down vote you but here are a few remarks about your comment:

>> [..] but it is a lot more efficient for some of them.

> Technically correct

Not quite. We know algorithms which have better time complexity on a quantum than any known classical algorithm that solves the same problem. Shor's algorithm is an example. We are not sure if a classical algorithm with the same time complexity exists.

>Factorization for example, that's why public key encryption works (we can't brute force it), but a quantum computer could.

Most (all?) modern public key algorithms are not based on the integer factorization problem.


> >Factorization for example, that's why public key encryption works (we can't brute force it), but a quantum computer could.

> Most (all?) modern public key algorithms are not based on the integer factorization problem.

There are analogues for Shor's algorithm for the discrete logarithm and other similar problems.


Shor's algorithm covers discrete logarithm also.

But most modern asymmetric algorithms are based on elliptic curves and other problems that quantum computers don't help with.


The ECC algorithms used today rely on the "Elliptic Curve Discrete Logarithm Problem" and are very much vulnerable to (a version of) Shor's algorithm. Some would even say they are more vulnerable than RSA due to the much smaller key sizes (requiring less qubits).


You can simulate a quantum circuit with a classical circuit, albeit with exponential slowdown.


My understanding is that the "magic" of a quantum computer is that it quickly finds a solution in a search space that grows exponentially based on the size of the input. Therefore it can be simulated by enumerating the search space and iterating over it.

The simulation is based on describing the problem in terms of quantum computing and translating that description into a program executable by a Turing machine. The simulation allows testing the utility/correctness of programs for quantum computers.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: