Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | nonethewiser's commentslogin

>I would argue that that's been the case for quite some time before AI.

I would agree but it's really minimized the building. More and more time is being spent on pre-coding work.


What models? Last I tried different local modals there was a pretty big difference from frontier.

This is just wrong. They are working AI into search so that AI does not cannablize search. Search goes hand-in-hand with ads.

Every single software engineer I know uses it pretty heavily.

Becasue they like it? Or becasue it happens to better then alternative tools we had?

Seems the main claims against it center around:

1. Labor replacement

2. AI is actually bad in-and-of-itself. Doesn't work, not useulf etc.

3. Energy concerns


The thing is, I hear those concerns a lot too, from people that are daily heavy users of AI.

I wonder how many still say they have a negative sentiment on AI yet are still paying customers.


I've also seen water usage concerns.

Yeah you'd need to support it in the term itself. So many queries coming from the url bar. As opposed to a toggle or something. I wonder if we have info on that - what percentage is input in address bar vs google homepage/app.

The problem is that's not discoverable though. The toggle on google.com would be nice but most people probably arent searching that way.


>I actually like AI mode in Google. My main reason is if I just have a quick question it seems a lot quicker than logging into ChatGPT/Claude as I can just type it in the address bar.

This is the exact use-case, and it makes a lot of sense. The hard part for Google is identifying when someone wants search and when someone wants an AI response. It's somewhat identifiable by the input but of course thats extremely messy to determine systematically.


Just do what Kagi does and turn on AI mode only if there's a "?" At the end of the query.

They are already doing something like that though. It's not just a ? mark, but they are getting some signal from the input and classifying it as a search term or AI prompt. Not all inputs have an AI response.

And a "?" at the end is not going to capture a lot of real LLM prompts like "What should I pack for my vaction? Im going to Florida in September."

I mean you could do something like this. But it's really not much different than other manual search codes that are used by more power users like like "", "site:" etc.

They probably have a term for it but their AI response is just another "embedded result" for lack of a better term. Like displaying the local weather directly at the top when you search "weather", etc.


It was funny how the other way when I searched for "nvm" to look up Node Version Manager, the AI mode thought I was saying "nevermind" to it. It felt quite jarring.

Not really. Dumping != flourishing

Thats not hard to believe. An immigrant wouldnt be a part of some native separatist movement.

Mini brexit? A province seceding from Canada is way bigger than the UK leaving the EU.

Mini Brexit in the sense that a foreign entity is working to destabilize another.

Russia and its proxies ran an active measures campaign in the UK. If the US government isn’t doing something similar, the toxic soup of the maga-sphere definitely is.


> A province seceding from Canada is way bigger than the UK leaving the EU

Genuinely debatable. The total economic destruction of Brexit has been far higher than anything Alberta would suffer. And geopolitically, Alberta wouldn’t take itself off the table the way the English have basically rendered the UK irrelevant.


What? The UK is doing better economically than Germany right now.

And better than anywhere in Europe for Tech with Deepmind and Ineffable Intelligence there.

It still shares many of the same mistakes as Europe though - e.g. now having to buy Russian oil and gas again instead of using the North Sea oil, not expanding nuclear power, rampant welfare and council housing corruption, etc.


> What? The UK is doing better economically than Germany right now.

By *near-instantaneous* (this year or this quarter) growth perhaps, but Brexit was a while ago and the 10-year growth was about 36.8% for Germany and about 25.1% for the UK: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=germany+gdp+2025%2Fgerm...

(That said, how each nation handled the pandemic is a massive confounding variable).

Germany is currently ahead by 1.2 trillion per year for nominal GDP, 1.7 trillion by PPP GDP, and also ahead on both nominal per capita and PPP per capita.

I agree there are some shared weaknesses, but oil and gas are now short-term thinking, and energy policy wasn't helped by (nor, fortunately, hurt by) Brexit.

AI, much as I like using it, I'm not at all clear who is going to get left holding the bag, in each of the various scenarios from "it's a bubble" to "and now we're post-scarcity" and everything between.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: